Are you into big-boned game hunts, say the likes of elk and deer? Well, it’s high time you stopped thinking in the lines of mechanical broadheads. They deliver remarkable cutting power, no doubt. But they don’t have the bone-crushing, deep-penetrating punch of fixed blade broadheads.
And that’s all that counts in the world of big game hunts. But not every fixed blade broadhead you come across is as good. You need the best fixed-blade broadheads the market has to offer.
Though not easy, choosing the best fixed-blade broadhead pays in the long run. I’m going to review the best picks for whatever budget or game you have in mind.
10 Best Fixed Blade Broadheads
1. G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead
G5 broadheads are among the most innovative and accurate. Opening our list is the Montec 3-pack broadhead.
Fixed 3-blade configuration
Montec broadhead adopts a one-piece stainless steel design. Hence, it’s extremely durable for heavy use. And since there’s no moving part, it requires little to no maintenance.
Well, fixed blade broadheads come in two, three, and four-blade configurations. So, with three blades, Montec is a happy medium. It’s well-balanced and with excellent penetration.
Tapered blade design
Fixed blade broadheads need sharpening. So, to make the task more convenient, Montec uses tapered, angled blades.
Field point accuracy
Wide blades often create more friction, lowering broadhead speed. Well, Montec adopts a small cutting diameter of 1 to 1-1/8 inches. Hence, it’s less prone to drifting or planning in wind conditions. As such, it offers a field point-like accuracy.
Montec has a cut-on-contact diamond tip. Hence, it offers excellent slicing with little energy. The result is maximum penetration power, ideal for low-poundage bows. It works in tandem with the small diameter to bring down large games, such as elk.
Montec is a 100-grain broadhead, the most common size. It’s lighter, resulting in less draw weight.
For an extremely durable broadhead for a pass-through shot, Montec will suffice. It might not boast the accuracy of mechanical broadheads. However, it promises field point accuracy, which is very reassuring.
Don’t Miss To Read: The 10 Best Ground Blind Chairs – Complete Buyer’s Guide
2. Rage Crossbow X 2-Blade Archery Broadhead
Rage is one of the pioneers of mechanical broadheads. It enters the list with the 2020s best bet, the Crossbow X broadhead.
2-blade mechanical design
The mechanical blades have the flying attributes of a field point. Hence, it rewards users with consistent flight performance. The result is maximum precision, with little to no bow tuning.
Crossbow X uses front-pivoting blades. They deploy outward for full-sized entrance and exit holes. Tell you what; this is the design you want for a maximum blood trail.
Advanced shock-collar technology
Crossbow X uses improved shock-collar technology. Hence, it affords better blade retention. Also, it enables the blades to open smoothly upon impact.
Massive cutting surface
Like other mechanical broadheads, Crossbow X delivers a more massive cut. At 2 inches in diameter, it results in a maximum blood trail. Hence, it’s quick and easy to recover your game.
Bone-breaking chisel tip
Chisel tip offers a consistent angle and trajectory. Also, it easily punches through tough hide and bone without damage.
Aluminum keeps the weight to a minimum. Also, Crossbow X has two weight options: 100 and 125-grain broadheads.
For consistent flight performance and maximum blood trail, Crossbow X will suffice. But it might need more energy to drive it home. So, I’d recommend it for high-poundage bows.
Don’t Miss To Read: The Best Ladder Stands for Bow Hunting – Check Our Top Picks!
3. G5 Outdoors Montec Carbon Steel Premium Broadheads
As mentioned earlier, G5 is a brand that establishes high standards. It presents yet another high-quality broadhead, the Montec premium.
Single-piece 3-blade configuration
This broadhead has single-piece carbon steel construction. Hence, it affords a high strength-to-weight ratio.
Tapered blade design
Well, the blades don’t sit straight. Instead, they’re angled. Hence, they’re easy to re-sharpen after heavy use.
Maximized blade edge
The original Montec blade is sharp, no doubt. But with additional honing, this carbon steel broadhead takes it the extra mile. It rewards you with 25% sharper blades than the original model.
This broadhead slices in an instant, delivering a 1-1/16-inch cutting diameter. And with diamond-tip design, it offers better penetration.
This broadhead boasts the same weight as the original Montec. At 100 grains, it doesn’t need as much energy to sent it home. Once again, it’s a good match for a low-poundage bow.
This is a fuss-free screw-and-shoot broadhead. I’d recommend it to a first-timer who needs that extra slicing power.
4. NAP Spitfire Crossbow Mechanical Broadhead
Mechanical broadheads offer unrivaled precision. However, they lack enough penetration power. But here’s a mechanical broadhead that provides the best of both worlds.
Micro-grooved 3-blade design
NAP Spitfire has a patented micro-grooved design. Hence, it rewards you with flight accuracy and excellent penetration power.
Also, the blades have a cutting diameter of 1-1/2 inches. Well, that’s smaller than what you get from other mechanical broadheads. Hence, it improves the penetration power even further. Also, you don’t need as much energy to draw.
Ultra-sharp diamize blades
NAP Spitfire doesn’t use standard blades. Instead, it uses diamond cutting blades. They’re the sharpest in the industry. Also, they provide the unmatched hardness of diamond.
Hardened bone splitting chisel tip
This broadhead boasts a legendary chisel-shaped trophy tip point. Same as the blades, it’s hardened for a bone-splitting punch. Moreover, it’s surprisingly durable.
NAP Spitfire is a 100-grain broadhead. Hence, it comes lighter for high flight speed.
For a mechanical broadhead with a more balanced design, NAP Spitfire will suffice. It has field point accuracy and a penetration power close to fixed broadheads. Overall, if you need more punch in a mechanical broadhead, Spitfire is for you.
5. Muzzy 209-MX4 Bow Hunting Broadhead
Muzzy is one brand that never ceases to impress. In fact, it’s the number one choice for fixed blade broadheads. It makes first entry on the list, courtesy of Muzzy 209-MX4 broadhead.
Lethal 4-blade design
More blades equal more slicing power. Well, that’s what you get with the MX4. It has four razor-sharp blades that pack remarkable cutting power. Also, the blades lock securely for ultimate strength. Such specs make it an ideal choice for taking down that legendary buck.
Bone-shattering hardened steel Trocar Tip
MX4 does more than pack exceptional cutting power. It also boasts a bone-shattering tip. And with a 1-1/8-inch cutting diameter, it delivers more penetration power.
Replaceable interlocking blades
The blades on the MX4 are replaceable. Hence, if you’re not into much sharpening, you can fit new ones.
MX4 is a 100-grain broadhead. Hence, it’s lighter for bow hunting.
For me, MX4 is pretty much a hybrid. It has the speed and slicing power of mechanical broadheads. Also, it affords the deeper penetration of fixed blade broadheads. So, it’s more of an all-around choice for bow hunting.
6. Muzzy Trocar Crossbow Archery Broadhead
Trocar crossbow broadhead is another expertly designed broadhead from Muzzy. It’s a fixed broadhead that promises exceptional quality and reliability.
3-blade right-helix design
Trocar crossbow broadhead boasts a right-helix design. It maximizes arrow stabilization for a smooth sail. Also, it offers field point-like accuracy.
I had the chance to have a look at different test speeds. Tell you what; this broadhead achieves an impressive 400 fps. So, it’s built for high-speed setups.
Hardened steel Trocar Tip
Much like the MX4, this broadhead has a hardened steel tip. It provides a bone-shattering impact and a clean, accurate hit. And with smaller 1-3/16-inch blades, it penetrates deeper.
Replaceable razor-sharp blades
The replaceable blade design gives you the convenience of using new blades. At the same time, they provide the robustness of single-piece versions.
Trocar crossbow broadhead is a versatile choice for all skill levels. Also, I’d commend it for delivering fast, accurate hits.
This broadhead is available in two weights: 100 and 125-grain versions. Either way, it offers a lighter setup for easy portability.
7. Drone Broadhead by Wasp Archery
Drone broadhead is hand-built for quality and precision. And when it comes to taking down big game, this broadhead is one step ahead.
Refined one-piece steel construction
The all-steel construction lends a refined look. Also, it offers a sturdy built, making it a heavy hitter. As such, it can drive through big game bones with ease. It’s pretty much what you’d need for a clean pass-through.
Aerodynamic 3-blade configuration
The aerodynamic blades provide a smooth-flying hit. It’s consistent and built for high speeds. And with 1-1/8-inch cutting diameter, deep penetration is guaranteed.
Precision-machined Trocar Tip
The pressed Trocar tip offers much-needed penetration power. It provides a clean pass-through, but with devastating impact. So, it’s pretty much a kill shot, all accurate and solid.
Drone broadhead comes in a 100-grain size. But there’s the option of a slightly larger 125-grain version.
I’d commend this broadhead for its high-impact penetration power. If you want more drive-through power, Drone broadhead will suit you.
8. Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead
Do you need a fixed blade that flies true in a crosswind? Well, Muzzy has this quality broadhead that deserves your attention.
Solid steel ferrule
This broadhead comes all tough and ready to take a hit. Thanks to solid steel ferrule, it offers excellent resistance to wear and splitting. Hence, it promises a longer lifespan.
Right-Helix 3-blade configuration
Muzzy Trocar Broadhead has razor-thin blades. But don’t let that fool you. The blades provide deadly slicing power to bring down any game.
Also, the blades are replaceable. So, you have the option of fitting new ones when the need arises.
Hardened steel Trocar Tip
Like other broadheads from Muzzy, you’re rewarded with a hardened steel tip. It provides a bone-obliterating shot. And considering the small 1-3/16-inch cutting diameter, the penetration power is remarkable.
This broadhead offers much-needed accuracy at long ranges. Also, it adopts a pretty sold design for superior penetration. I’d say it’s an all-around choice for any hunting sport.
9. Muzzy 100 4-Blade Bow Hunting Broadhead
I’m the type who loves going lighter. However, not at the expense of flight consistency and penetration power. Well, such specs define Muzzy 100 broadheads.
Four vented stainless steel blades
Since it packs more blades, Muzzy 100 delivers a more vicious cut. Also, it uses vented blades instead of solid blades. Well, some might argue there’s no difference. But here’s the thing. Hollow-ground blades provide exceptional penetrating power.
Also, the blades are thinner and lighter. For this reason, they pack significant slicing power. Hence, they offer better blood trails than thicker blades.
Trocar Tip & smaller cutting diameter
Muzzy 100 has the best combination for deeper penetrating power. It’s equipped with a hardened steel tip and a 1-inch cutting diameter. Hence, it crushes and penetrates deeper.
As mentioned, Muzzy 100 comes lighter at 90 and 100 grains. It’s pretty much what you’d need for long-range shots.
Muzzy 100 packs all the features you need for a dead-accurate long shot. Head-to-head, it has better penetration power than 4-blade counterparts.
10. Carbon Express Nativ 100 Broadhead
Do you want the deepest penetration from any bow setup? If so, a fixed 2-blade broadhead is an ultimate choice. For that, I won’t go further than the Carbon Express broadhead.
Solid 2-blade design
The secret to its remarkable penetration power lies with the 2-blade design and a smaller 1-1/8-inch cutting diameter. Such configuration allows for effortless slicing. And unlike three and four fixed-blade setups, it’s much easier to sharpen.
Superior lightweight strength
Fewer blades cut down on the weight. And with air-craft grade aluminum ferrule, you get a lighter broadhead. Another catch is that it offers superior strength for high-impact shots.
Carbon Express affords a more versatile design. And it’s largely due to the lighter weight. Hence, it’s as good for low-poundage bows as it’s for high-poundage bows. Not to mention, it requires less tuning.
Like others on the list, Carbon Express is a 100-grain broadhead. It’s lighter but with sufficient driving force.
For a versatile design and deepest penetration, Carbon Express is your best bet. I’d say it’s a better way to start your broadhead journey.
Best Fixed Blade Broadhead: Complete Buyer’s Guide
Style is pretty much the first thing to consider. So far, there are two distinct styles: a one-piece blade and a replaceable fixed blade.
One-piece broadheads are fashioned from a single piece of material. Hence, they’re extremely durable. However, they require sharpening after heavy use. Plus, any damage on the blades calls for complete replacement.
Replaceable fixed blade designs give the option of fitting new blades. They’re robust, but not as single-piece broadheads.
Fixed blade broadheads can be further broken down in terms of blade configuration. You’ll get them in two, three, and four-blade configurations.
Well, more blades pack more slicing power. So, for a maximum blood trail, a broadhead with more blades is better. On the other hand, fewer blades reward you with the deepest penetration.
Do you want maximum blood trail or boosted penetration power? For maximum blood trail, choose a cutting diameter that’s more than 1-1/2 inches. But for deep penetration, 1-1/2 inches or less is okay.
More often, small blade diameters work best for big-boned animals. So, if you want the best fixed-blade broadhead for elk, you ought to go smaller.
Cutting length is the combined length of the blades’ surface area. Some refer to it as the total cut. Whichever way, it’s the main driving force behind your broadhead.
Broadheads that are 2 inches in length are the best for deer-sized animals. But ensure there’s sufficient pounding force to drive them home. For elk and other big games, consider a bow with 65 foot-pound draw energy.
Though often ignored, the tip of your broadhead is crucial. For maximum penetration, consider chisel or razor tip broadheads. Well, this is crucial for taking down big game. On the other hand, a blunt tip works fine for small game. After all, you don’t want to waste meat.
The durability of the broadhead tip also plays center stage. For bone-crushing penetration, go for nothing less than hardened steel.
Weight is another thing you ought to consider. For lightweight performance, go for 100-grain broadheads. Most often, they come in carbon and lightweight aluminum shafts. But it won’t hurt to go for 125-grain broadheads.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What’s the best fixed-blade broadhead for crossbow hunting?
Crossbows tend to shoot faster. Hence, I’d recommend broadheads with smaller fixed blades. Also, 100 or 125-grain will be perfect. All broadheads I’ve reviewed meet such criteria. So, it all depends on your budget.
What’s the best fixed-blade broadhead for whitetail deer?
Well, I’d settle for Rage Crossbow X broadhead. It provides a more aerodynamic flight and maximum blood trail.
What’s the best fixed-blade broadhead for elk and other large game?
I’d go for two options. First, I’d recommend Muzzy Trocar 125-Grain broadhead. It has more driving force for a bone-shattering punch. Also, it’s more stabilized for surgical precision.
The second option would be G5 Montec broadhead. It’s as tough as they come, making it the most deadly. Also, it’s well-balanced, and with exceptional slicing power.
I hope you now know what the best fixed-blade broadheads entail. Not only that, but you also have an idea of what models deserve the most attention. So, I feel I’ve pretty done my part. As for picking the best from the list, I leave it up to you. After all, you know your needs and budget the best.